no script

What’s patriarchy, ya?- By- Paromita Vohra

 So given her job, I guess the honourable minister knew whereof she spoke. It’s not just patriarchy that’s holding women back. It’s, erm, the economy.

It’s funny that, as per her recent talk at a Bengaluru University, Nirmala Sitharaman thinks patriarchy is a Leftist concept because not that long ago the Left considered patriarchy a plot to undermine the class struggle

But well, Nirmalaji is not the  Minister of History  but of Finance. And she is right about one thing. Sonalde Desai wrote last week in the Indian Express, research has found that while women’s agency, education, age of marriage, capacity to negotiate within families, all have shown positive growth in the last decade, it is not so when it comes to jobs. Women interviewed during the India Human Development Survey by the National Council for Applied Research and the University of Maryland, said their families would not hold them back from working if jobs could be found. So given her job, I guess the honourable minister knew whereof she spoke. It’s not just patriarchy that’s holding women back. It’s, erm, the economy.


Nirmalaji agreed that women are not being “adequately facilitated” (yaniki patriarchy?), but warned us about what would happen if we bandied the P word (yaniki patriarchy) around too much: families would fall apart. Why families should fall apart if we discuss inequality or violence is a mystery—unless inequality and violence are some of the ghar ki baatein that are supposed to remain ghar mein. Said the minister, no woman can do anything without family “to fall back on”

Family need not be such a fall-back compulsion if the State actually provided good health care, pensions, subsidised education and employment—neither for the poor nor for women who must leave families because of violence. Preserving myths about happy families preserves patriarchy and absolves governments of social responsibility so we can all focus on making rich people richer. It also makes invisible both, the suffering of people, and the new paths they choose.

This question was at the heart of a video from an LGBTiQA conference in South Africa  that went viral last week. As the lawyers Menaka Guruswamy and Arundhati Katju, celebrated for their involvement in the reading down of Section 377, delivered a keynote about solidarities and the marriage equality petition, queer indigenous activist Rituparna Borah asked a question. By taking centre stage as poster people of queer activism, did they not homogenise, even hijack, the variegated histories of queer activism—political, legal, cultural—that had led up to the acknowledgement of queer rights in India?

The demand for marriage equality, she said, did not represent the desires and needs of the entire queer community. Among the marriage equality petitions was also one—Rituparna Borah vs Union of India—that asked not for the right to marry, but the right to choose one’s own family or version of family, aka relational equality. The lawyer Vrinda Grover argued, trans and queer people have faced tremendous violence at the hands of their families, “and that is an example of what would happen if other social formations of care and support did not exist”. 

What’s patriarchy, ya? It’s what enables so much violence, loneliness and hardship structure. Violence that is used to keep people within caste, religion, heterosexuality and gender lines. Sure, for some family is a warm, safe haven. But only those who benefit from the privilege families preserve can be so unkind as to suggest we should imagine nothing else.

Paromita Vohra is an award-winning Mumbai-based filmmaker, writer and curator working with fiction and non-fiction.

<script async src="https://pagead2.googlesyndication.com/pagead/js/adsbygoogle.js?client=ca-pub-1207462075697587"
     crossorigin="anonymous"></script>

Loading

  • Kumar Bahukhandi

    Kumar Bahukhandi is a journalist, educator and writer, and an Assistant Professor of Journalism and Mass Communication. He is the Founder and Editor of Channel24India and Editor of Prime Look – The International Research Journal and Prime Review. His writing explores human behaviour, relationships, emotions and the choices that shape everyday life. Through journalism, short stories and reflective essays, he brings together academic inquiry and a curiosity about people. Guided by the principle of “simple living and high thinking”, Kumar values authenticity, modesty and respect for every individual, regardless of status or background. He believes in remaining true to himself, listening to his inner voice and finding meaning in ordinary experiences.

    Related Posts

    Ahead of Diwali, Mahtari Vandan’s 33rd Instalment Reaches 67.40 Lakh Women in Chhattisgarh-By Dhananjay Rathore

    Union Home and Cooperation Minister Amit Shah releases the 33rd instalment of the Mahtari Vandan Yojana in the presence of Chief Minister Vishnu Deo Sai at the Chhattisgarh Rajyotsav closing…

    Loading

    From Security Camps to Service Centres: Bastar’s Story of Change Takes Shape in Gundadhur’s Homeland-By Dhananjay Rathore

    Union Home and Cooperation Minister Amit Shah interacts with local women alongside Chief Minister Vishnu Deo Sai at Netanar in Bastar district in this edited feature graphic illustrating the Shaheed…

    Loading

    You Missed

    Sai inaugurates 97 projects, lays foundation stones for 178 works in Suhela

    Sai inaugurates 97 projects, lays foundation stones for 178 works in Suhela

    US court seeks Delhi courts’ help to serve summonses on Doval and Goel. What does it mean?

    US court seeks Delhi courts’ help to serve summonses on Doval and Goel. What does it mean?

    Trump, Xi and Putin hold historic Shenzhen summit, pledge nuclear talks

    Trump, Xi and Putin hold historic Shenzhen summit, pledge nuclear talks

    Chhattisgarh receives investment proposals worth over ₹1.07 lakh crore at Industry Dialogue

    Chhattisgarh receives investment proposals worth over ₹1.07 lakh crore at Industry Dialogue

    Chhattisgarh proposes PPP model for 207 IGNITE schools, will retain full ownership of assets

    Chhattisgarh proposes PPP model for 207 IGNITE schools, will retain full ownership of assets

    Chhattisgarh to receive four national awards for implementing PM SVANidhi

    Chhattisgarh to receive four national awards for implementing PM SVANidhi