SC overturns ’90 verdict on industrial alcohol

New Delhi: The Supreme Court in an 8:1 majority verdict on Wednesday October 23,2024  overturned a seven-judge bench judgment and held that the states have regulatory power over production, manufacture and supply of industrial alcohol.

Industrial alcohol refers to denatured alcohol which is unfit for human consumption. Chemical compound ethyl alcohol (95 per cent concentration) is an industrial form of alcohol.

The apex court held that the phrase “intoxicating liquor” in Entry 8 of the State List in the Seventh Schedule of the Constitution would include industrial alcohol within its ambit.

The majority bench comprised Chief Justice of India D.Y. Chandrachud and Justices Hrishikesh Roy, Abhay S. Oka, J.B. Pardiwala, Manoj Misra, Ujjal Bhuyan, Satish Chandra Sharma and Augustine George Masih.

Justice B.V. Nagarathna, however, dissented and held that states did not have the legislative competence to regulate industrial alcohol or denatured spirit.

The majority verdict overturned a 1990 seven-judge bench verdict in Synthetics & Chemicals Ltd. Vs. State of Uttar Pradesh holding that the centre had the regulatory power over the production of industrial alcohol.

The CJI, who penned the majority verdict, also writing on behalf of the seven judges, said Entry 8 sought to regulate everything from “raw materials to production of intoxicating liquor”.

In its 364-page judgment, the top court said: “Parliament cannot occupy the field of the entire industry merely by issuing a declaration under Entry 52 of List I. The state legislature’s competence under Entry 24 of List II is denuded only to the extent of the field covered by the law of Parliament under Entry 52 of List I.”

Parliament does not have the legislative competence to enact a law taking control of the industry of intoxicating liquor, reads the verdict.

The judgment said the phrase “intoxicating liquor” in Entry 8 included all alcoholic liquids which could harm public health. While Entry 8 in the State List under the 7th Schedule of the Constitution gives the states the power to legislate on the manufacture, possession, transport, purchase and sale of “intoxicating liquors”, Entry 52 of the Union List and Entry 33 of the Concurrent List mention industries whose control was “declared by Parliament by law to be expedient in public interest”.

Both Parliament and state legislatures can enact laws on the subjects mentioned in the Concurrent List. However, a Central law will have primacy over the state law.

Several state governments including Uttar Pradesh had challenged the seven-judge bench judgment and countered Centre’s position that it had exclusive control over industrial alcohol.

The Union government referred to its power in Entry 52 of the Union List, which said “industries, the control of which by the Union is declared by Parliament by law to be expedient in public interest”.

Asserting its regulatory right over industrial alcohol, the Centre had contended that framers of the Constitution intended to give it complete control over any industry through enactment of Industrial (Development and Regulation) Act, 1951 in “public interest”.
( Source D C)

Loading

  • Kumar Bahukhandi

    Kumar has written mostly short stories and on human behavior that changed the day to day course of the people who engineered them. He says I am always myself... I just hate being someone else...It's so fake and unreal..."!!I have an everyday religion that works for me. Love yourself first, and everything else falls into line...... I am just a next door person A friend of friends, A Journalist ,who respects every person regardless of his/her stature (but yes, disregards cunning and selfish people).Learnt to get in touch with the silence within myself and knew that everything in life has a purpose. A very simple, Introvert person who believe in "Simple Living and High Thinking", trusts in Modesty. Very truthful to self basic instincts, work, hobbies and family. I Always Listen and Obey what my heart, my inner voice, my soul tells me. I prefer to be true to myself, even at the hazard of incurring the ridicule of others.

    Related Posts

    Chargesheet filed in Sambhal violence: Chargesheet is of 4175 pages against 208 accused, entire incident mentioned in detail

    Chandausi Court – Photo : Samvad The police has filed a 4175-page chargesheet against 208 accused in six cases of violence that took place on November 24 during the Sambhal…

    Loading

    What Ranveer Allahbadia’s Lawyer Abhinav Chandrachud Said In Supreme Court: ‘I Am Personally Disgusted But…’

    Advocate Abhinav Chandrachud, a Bombay High Court lawyer and the son of former Chief Justice of India DY Chandrachud, represented YouTuber Ranveer Allahbadia in the Supreme Court on Tuesday February…

    Loading

    You Missed

    Proud Wife Anushka Sharma Lauds Virat Kohli’s Historic 51st ODI Century In India vs Pakistan Match

    Proud Wife Anushka Sharma Lauds Virat Kohli’s Historic 51st ODI Century In India vs Pakistan Match

    Laxman Utekar Apologises After Ganoji, Kanhoji Shirke Descendants Accuse Chhaava Of ‘Misinterpreting Historical Facts’

    Laxman Utekar Apologises After Ganoji, Kanhoji Shirke Descendants Accuse Chhaava Of ‘Misinterpreting Historical Facts’

    Virat Kohli Creates History, Breaks Sachin Tendulkar’s World Record, Becomes Fastest Batsman To…

    Virat Kohli Creates History, Breaks Sachin Tendulkar’s World Record, Becomes Fastest Batsman To…

    IND vs PAK: India avenged its defeat in the 2017 Champions Trophy final against Pakistan and also made it to the semi-finals

    IND vs PAK: India avenged its defeat in the 2017 Champions Trophy final against Pakistan and also made it to the semi-finals

    IND vs PAK Live Score: Kuldeep Yadav wreaks havoc… Pakistani team all out, India gets a target of 242 runs to win

    IND vs PAK Live Score: Kuldeep Yadav wreaks havoc… Pakistani team all out, India gets a target of 242 runs to win

    Atishi will be the Leader of Opposition in Delhi Assembly, decision taken in the AAP Legislature Party meeting

    Atishi will be the Leader of Opposition in Delhi Assembly, decision taken in the AAP Legislature Party meeting